Need advice on roof building

I am constructing a castle and I just finished putting up the walls. The building has a large footprint (something like 15-20x15-20 and a slight L shape. The typical straight angle roof I normally use for wood structures will not work here due to both the shape and footprint of the structure. (the roof would be taller than the structure itself) Using stone pads for the roof is also not really viable given how large most of the rooms are so I don't really know how to cover this structure. Does anyone have any suggestions?
2:13 am, May 19, 2023
Joseph Sneed 0 comments 0 likes

Jitatha replied to Need advice on roof building May 20, 2023 @ 5:49:36 am PDT

Yeah that works, looks ok as well. When upgrade to the tile based roof it will look better.

If you look at an actual longhouse you will see that so much of it, is just roof. But I would like to see a whole bunch more roofing options so that a curved ridge roof is possible. Even a stepped ridge roof is tricky and time consuming given standard building block is 1m, a 0.5m piece would be useful in roofing.

https://www.visitdenmark.com/press/latest-news/denmarks-largest-viking-longhouse-opens
2:13 pm, May 20, 2023
0 comments 0 likes

Frank Dunn replied to Need advice on roof building May 19, 2023 @ 12:22:43 pm PDT

https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2977913108

If this posts correctly, here is a picture of my roof I made, it uses both the outward and inward corner pieces. Coming in from all sides saves on height.
8:13 pm, May 19, 2023
0 comments 0 likes

Jitatha replied to Need advice on roof building May 19, 2023 @ 8:54:45 am PDT

Iron framed stone works well, but depends on what you want. If happy to use columns do that. Dont forget if you place fast enough you can squeeze blocks together that would normally collaape.

https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2789093820
5:13 pm, May 19, 2023
0 comments 0 likes

Jitatha replied to Need advice on roof building May 19, 2023 @ 9:00:47 am PDT

Dont want to use iron?
Then this
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2880108793

Iron can be seen due to building very high, but your building is not big enough to need it yet.
5:13 pm, May 19, 2023
0 comments 0 likes

Sockwallet replied to Need advice on roof building May 19, 2023 @ 1:31:21 am PDT

What I ended up doing was watching a few build vids from other people and learned how they solved the problem and it worked for me.
11:13 am, May 19, 2023
0 comments 0 likes

knighttemplar1960 replied to Need advice on roof building May 18, 2023 @ 10:31:43 pm PDT

If it is just for aesthetics you can use the corrugated cardboard trick. Drop down 1 meter and put wood flooring on, alternate 26 degree thatch roofing to make the corrugations, and put wood flooring on top of that. Looks smooth from the top and the bottom and keeps the weather out. The top floor tiles weather down to 50% health but no farther. You can cut a smoke hole through and put a chimney cap over that to let smoke out if the inner roof is too close to the fire to allow dissipation.
8:13 am, May 19, 2023
0 comments 0 likes

Frank Dunn replied to Need advice on roof building May 18, 2023 @ 5:02:10 pm PDT

Have you been using a typical "A" frame roof until now and not joining perpendicular section together? If you have an L shape, the corner pieces in the build menu will help you fill in the odd shape, you will have to experiment. To avoid a super high roof, you can use the 26 degree shingles or build it up from all of your walls simultaneously.

It's a little hard for me to describe, but try building a 4x4 structure and have 2 regular shingles in the middle sections all around and use the corner pieces in the four corners. It takes practice, at least it did for me. I hope that helps.
2:13 am, May 19, 2023
0 comments 0 likes

Joseph Sneed replied to Need advice on roof building May 18, 2023 @ 5:12:17 pm PDT

Originally posted by Frank Dunn:
Have you been using a typical "A" frame roof until now and not joining perpendicular section together? If you have an L shape, the corner pieces in the build menu will help you fill in the odd shape, you will have to experiment. To avoid a super high roof, you can use the 26 degree shingles or build it up from all of your walls simultaneously.

It's a little hard for me to describe, but try building a 4x4 structure and have 2 regular shingles in the middle sections all around and use the corner pieces in the four corners. It takes practice, at least it did for me. I hope that helps.
Yeah I have been using A frame so far. When I say L it is barely an L The section sticking out is like 10-15 floors long when the longest point is 15-20. This is kind of why it is a problem as it is practically a 20x20 box and even with the shorter roof parts the roof will still end up almost as tall as the structure itself.
2:13 am, May 19, 2023
0 comments 0 likes

sarteck replied to Need advice on roof building May 18, 2023 @ 5:19:21 pm PDT

Could you provide a few screenshots to give a better idea of what the uncovered areas you want to fill in look like?
2:13 am, May 19, 2023
0 comments 0 likes

Joseph Sneed replied to Need advice on roof building May 18, 2023 @ 5:33:31 pm PDT

Originally posted by sarteck:
Could you provide a few screenshots to give a better idea of what the uncovered areas you want to fill in look like?
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2977590231
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2977590252
The roofs that are currently there are temporary.
2:13 am, May 19, 2023
0 comments 0 likes

sarteck replied to Need advice on roof building May 18, 2023 @ 6:53:20 pm PDT

Originally posted by Joseph Sneed:
Originally posted by sarteck:
Could you provide a few screenshots to give a better idea of what the uncovered areas you want to fill in look like?
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2977590231
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2977590252
The roofs that are currently there are temporary.
If you use the stone pillars, you should be able to support the stone floor 2x2 as roofs. You likely won't even need them in those areas that have temporary roofs.

What's the goal here? You don't want the roofs to rise above the walls? You don't want to use thatch roofs? You want flat roofs and/or ceilings?
2:13 am, May 19, 2023
0 comments 0 likes

Joseph Sneed replied to Need advice on roof building May 18, 2023 @ 7:11:31 pm PDT

Originally posted by sarteck:
Originally posted by Joseph Sneed:
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2977590231
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2977590252
The roofs that are currently there are temporary.
If you use the stone pillars, you should be able to support the stone floor 2x2 as roofs. You likely won't even need them in those areas that have temporary roofs.

What's the goal here? You don't want the roofs to rise above the walls? You don't want to use thatch roofs? You want flat roofs and/or ceilings?
I just did not want the roof to be the same size as the building itself as it would look stupid. I took the advice in the prior post and used iron beams to support the roof and used stone everywhere other than the foundry as I would have to raise the entire structure up another block to be high enough for the smelters and it needs ventilation anyway.
2:13 am, May 19, 2023
0 comments 0 likes