? Don't understand the problem... one planted seed = one tree ...

I think he's talking about the seed drop rate.

Planted should drop 1 seed per. Or alternately drop a seed or two every N days (say 5) so that cutting them is a choice / decision point.

Trees and ore are the only non renewable resource really. Its possible to run a world totally out of them, since every tree cut has a small chance for a seed that then has a small chance for a seed, eventually ... no seeds, no trees. Granted, world is plenty big so its a non issue.

i get all of it but again think that since the game has many ways to cheeze items it would be nice if the things we Actually Cultivated had a hair higher drop rate... maybe two seeds for one tree cut down... since time to grow, plant... anyway its just my two cents :)

Sry, my english isn't very well. Hm I never run out of trees and I have enough seeds. But I don't know how much you've build, that you needed so much wood, that it's possible you run out of it...

I end up having way too many beech seeds. Firs also drop a lot of cones. But the higher quality wood trees have a lower drop rate that you may need to replenish from the wild. I get a few birch and pine seeds, but not enough to fully sustain a farm without going back to the wild. It's better than it used to be though. I'm not sure about oak because I usually leave those alone.

deforestation is real. be cognizant of it,

All the seed drop rates are less than one, and trees don't spread out or respawn. It is technically possible to run out of trees, but the effort required is the stuff of legends. It may be a hazard for 1000 or 2000+ days, but it's still possible to renew wood by hunting greydwarves.

It'd be nice to perhaps be able to purchase tree seeds from the trader, or offer another trader with special purchases.

and i get why they did it but when you can use generators like fire under a grey dwarf spawn it does not reward a player for cultivation.. to me.

someone mentioned tress dropping seeds every few days. Cultivated the crap out of some trees this week while our server was life (so plenty of game days) and nada. Still think all trees Cultivated should have a return but I can absolutely say not a acorn or a birch seed dropped at all from the ones I planted.

I end up having way too many beech seeds. Firs also drop a lot of cones. But the higher quality wood trees have a lower drop rate that you may need to replenish from the wild. I get a few birch and pine seeds, but not enough to fully sustain a farm without going back to the wild. It's better than it used to be though. I'm not sure about oak because I usually leave those alone.

deforestation is real. be cognizant of it,

All the seed drop rates are less than one, and trees don't spread out or respawn. It is technically possible to run out of trees, but the effort required is the stuff of legends. It may be a hazard for 1000 or 2000+ days, but it's still possible to renew wood by hunting greydwarves.

It'd be nice to perhaps be able to purchase tree seeds from the trader, or offer another trader with special purchases.

and i get why they did it but when you can use generators like fire under a grey dwarf spawn it does not reward a player for cultivation.. to me.

? Don't understand the problem... one planted seed = one tree ...

I think he's talking about the seed drop rate.

Planted should drop 1 seed per. Or alternately drop a seed or two every N days (say 5) so that cutting them is a choice / decision point.

Trees and ore are the only non renewable resource really. Its possible to run a world totally out of them, since every tree cut has a small chance for a seed that then has a small chance for a seed, eventually ... no seeds, no trees. Granted, world is plenty big so its a non issue.

i get all of it but again think that since the game has many ways to cheeze items it would be nice if the things we Actually Cultivated had a hair higher drop rate... maybe two seeds for one tree cut down... since time to grow, plant... anyway its just my two cents :)

Sry, my english isn't very well. Hm I never run out of trees and I have enough seeds. But I don't know how much you've build, that you needed so much wood, that it's possible you run out of it...