Originally posted by grapplehoeker:

Originally posted by Isaac_Clark:

Did you forget that Frostner deals magical Frost damage? And the Draugr Fang glows like something out of Lord of the Rings. Pretty sure the limited amount of guck it takes to make isn't responsible for it being able to add poison damage to every arrow fired from it.
And I wasn't counting silver as magic damge; if I was I would have included the Silver Sword.

Heh... yes, right. I did forget about Frostner's frost damage. My bad ;)
Swamp Guck glows in the dark naturally though which means the bow glows naturally and not magically. As for the arrows, they're poisonous because the Ooze you craft them from is naturally poisonous.
Silver sword deals spirit damage to those supernatural creatures vulnerable to spirit damage as I stated above. That's more of a natural vulnerability to an inherently natural property than a magical one.

Originally posted by grapplehoeker:

Originally posted by Isaac_Clark:

Did you forget that Frostner deals magical Frost damage? And the Draugr Fang glows like something out of Lord of the Rings. Pretty sure the limited amount of guck it takes to make isn't responsible for it being able to add poison damage to every arrow fired from it.
And I wasn't counting silver as magic damge; if I was I would have included the Silver Sword.

Heh... yes, right. I did forget about Frostner's frost damage. My bad ;)
Swamp Guck glows in the dark naturally though which means the bow glows naturally and not magically. As for the arrows, they're poisonous because the Ooze you craft them from is naturally poisonous.
Silver sword deals spirit damage to those supernatural creatures vulnerable to spirit damage as I stated above. That's more of a natural vulnerability to an inherently natural property than a magical one.

Originally posted by wizard_of_woz:

Except the arrows have nothing be to do with the bow. You can use normal wood arrows and they become poisonous, I would definitely call that magical.

Originally posted by Weaver:

Not true about Draugr Fang. You don't use Ooze to craft the bow, so your argument that "they're poisonous because the ooze you craft them from is naturally poisonous" doesn't even follow. ANY arrow fired from Draugr Fang does poison damage, no Ooze involved.
The Gunk used in crafting the bow isn't used to make any other poison damage, and the limited amount used couldn't poison endless arrows even if it was, without the use of magic.

Originally posted by grapplehoeker:

Originally posted by wizard_of_woz:

Except the arrows have nothing be to do with the bow. You can use normal wood arrows and they become poisonous, I would definitely call that magical.

Originally posted by Weaver:

Not true about Draugr Fang. You don't use Ooze to craft the bow, so your argument that "they're poisonous because the ooze you craft them from is naturally poisonous" doesn't even follow. ANY arrow fired from Draugr Fang does poison damage, no Ooze involved.
The Gunk used in crafting the bow isn't used to make any other poison damage, and the limited amount used couldn't poison endless arrows even if it was, without the use of magic.

Please read my post again chaps ;)

Originally posted by Weaver:

Originally posted by grapplehoeker:

Please read my post again chaps ;)

We did.
Your argument to paraphrase is "uh, Gunk is poisonous even though there is nothing in the game to indicate it, and uh, SOOOOO poisonous it can make infinite poison arrows in a uh totally non-magical way"
In other words, its not a valid argument in the slightest.

Originally posted by Isaac_Clark:

Magic weapons and ammo become available after the third boss. Only two craftable magic weapons are currently the Frostner warhammer and the Draugr Fang bow.

Originally posted by grapplehoeker:

Weapons that may deal additional damage of a sort that is due to a vulnerability to that property doesn't make them magical as such.
In as much as any silver weapon will deal spirit damage (including Frostner), I suppose you might call that enchanted but not magical as such. Silver may be anathema to undead and werefolk, but that is more of an inherent property in much the same way as iron was anathema to the feyfolk.
As for the Draugr Fang, that deals Swamp Guck poison, pure and simple and not exactly magical.