Originally posted by Requimatic:

Don't bother with Onion Soup, it's both inferior to Eyescream and requires 3 times the amount of Onions to sustain.

Only problem with Eyescream is that it requires 3 Greydwarf Eyes and 1 Freeze Gland.. both items having alternate purposes that are rather important. (Portals and Frost Arrows respectively.)

Quite correct on all counts. But if you have gamed the system as I have, and gotten onion seeds about the same time as carrot by taking a little lucky covert trip to the mountains, you will have onions shooting out your ears.

And with there being only 1 health point and 5 stamina points difference onion soup is not that "inferior" to Eyescream, and farming glands is not that hard, but a bit tiresome...