I think Mistlands lost it for me, however before the nerf patch I completely hooked. I think all that needed changes was to lower gjall spawn. Before the nerfs it felt like a wild challenge and that sold all the mechanics, it made it feel more rewarding to unlock magic than a grindy chore that it is now. Now I have no desire to revisit, grind, or explore since it's just a chore. The best part about this patch now is the fishing, but even that system seems a bit barebones with only 1 or 2 unique recipes for the rest of the game. With plains I somehow still had desire to farm, make chests, tar, food. Black Marble really needs a buff and the nerfs of Mistlands need to be reversed.