Originally posted by Goril:

Ok guys but some fishes are not taking the bait. I tried all but only vendor's bait seems to working. :)) I also made baits from jumping fishes

I only really made it up to the swamp with the beta but it seems that Haldor's bait is only useful for the meadows, the other baits appear to be crafted from biome specific trophy drops.

When they won't take the bait try the bait from the biome.