Originally posted by Webbman:

sounds more like a whine than a review TBH. ... A hopping enemy, flying enemy, and a tank enemy. Then there's the dvergr thrown into the mix not to mention the chicken farming and fishing. The dungeons are well done and the sound work is really well done. The biome looks great and unique.

they could of easily replaced the magic system with a minigun, shield generator and grenade launcher i guess.....

I didn't read him as whining at all, but bringing to light the things he personally felt were lacking. This doesn't imply he found nothing good. Indeed, he said some of his group thought the things he felt were poor were in fact good.

You really do bring to light some good things - I think fair to say most will agree (not myself though) - but they seem not to outweigh the bad things. Surely the OP didn't miss those things you mention...

Your last statement is essentially saying: Its not as bad as it could have been. But if a discussion comes to that conclusion, we have to ask: "What went so wrong that this is the statement we're left with?" Trying to console ourselves by saying "It is not as bad as it could have been," is not a happy ending.

Cheers!