Originally posted by jonnin:

I think your #s assume you get 1 fish for every bait. That is NOT my experience in general.
You can't get enough of these guys to justify the time sink unless you enjoy fishing. In the time you can catch 1 stack of fish and bread, you could have planted and harvested the stuff to make (assuming you did something else while it grows) 20 or more stacks of salad.

I do recommend getting enough to make some for boss fights or even troublesome areas like the mines, but its just not worth it to me (and I do like to fish) to catch enough to eat this all the time.

Pretty much this. Went to the effort to get about 40 fish n bread for me and my wife for the Queen fights (we kill every boss twice). But otherwise, we use mushroom omelet and salad for general purpose stamina food in the Mistlands. Anywhere else, I just use bread. Actually I don't use any of it much anymore as I use 2 eitr foods and honey glazed chicken most of the time, as I have been doing the mage thing mostly as of late. Anyhow, Fish n Bread is mostly fine as it is. It's the absolute best, and if you want the absolute best stamina food, put in the work. If you're ok with something nearly as good, then there are much easier options that are nearly as good. It's definitely not worth it for routine use. But it's nice to have for when you want every advantage you can get.