Originally posted by jrc:

Please explain to me why I can't put the fish on a stuck and roast it. If that doesn't seem strange to you, I don't know what would.

IMO, the boss fights... at least the first couple, have been nerfed pretty hard. I did SP back when the game first came out, before the nerfs, and I remember having a much harder time.

You can roast fish but you need to clean it first using the cauldron.